Nathan Lane plays Chauncey Miles, an actor performing the nance role in one of these burlesque shows, except with one major twist, Chauncey actually is gay in real life. He meets Ned, a guy who's just arrived in the city homeless after leaving his wife behind. Chauncey initially assumes Ned's just a curious straight guy, but Ned tells him he's actually gay too. The two of them fall into a relationship, and Chauncey helps Ned land a job at the theater. Meanwhile, Mayor La Guardia's cracking down hard on burlesque as morally corrupt. Ephraim, who manages the theater, warns Chauncey that being openly gay is drawing attention from both gay audience members and the police. Chauncey, who's actually a Republican and supports La Guardia politically, assumes it'll all blow over eventually. During one show, with police sitting in the crowd, Chauncey defiantly plays up the nance role and kisses Ephraim right on stage, which leads to the theater getting raided. Chauncey gets thrown in jail briefly, and rather than feeling proud, he resents being treated like some kind of hero, growing increasingly bitter as burlesque keeps getting shut down further. His relationship with Ned starts falling apart as he drifts back to anonymous hookups in the park. Ned, who's become much more comfortable in his own identity by this point, asks Chauncey to commit to monogamy. Chauncey agrees, then breaks that promise almost immediately. When Ned catches him cruising again, Chauncey coldly pushes him away, admitting he actually wants to be used and thrown aside. Sensing that burlesque is basically finished anyway, Ned takes a touring job elsewhere and makes one final offer for Chauncey to come with him and actually try being monogamous. Chauncey turns him down, admitting to deep self hatred, and kisses Ned goodbye, only to get arrested for public indecency moments later. Later on, Chauncey performs in full drag and has a breakdown mid performance. The theater eventually shuts down. Facing charges as a repeat offender, he's offered a lighter sentence if he names Ned, but he refuses to give him up. Standing alone on stage as everyone around him leaves, he sings his signature song while part of the ceiling collapses nearby, and the curtain falls with him standing under a broken spotlight.
What really drives this play is the unlikely bond between these two men and the internal battle Chauncey fights, a man so weighed down by self loathing that he struggles to love anyone or believe he even deserves love himself. Ned, who left behind a marriage upstate to explore who he really is, falls for him completely, and his emotional openness and unwavering devotion slowly chip away at Chauncey's guardedness. Both lead actors do a genuinely excellent job portraying how their romance develops. That said, for me personally, the burlesque comedy and song interludes that satirically mirror what's happening in Chauncey and Ned's story started to drag after a while, though honestly that might just be my own attention span talking. The performances themselves are excellent, and I'm pretty sure I would've enjoyed this a lot more watching it live in a theater. The production quality is genuinely top notch, and so is the acting across the board. It's really just my own personal limitations that kept me from enjoying this as much as I probably should have. Chauncey Miles might be ahead of his time in some ways, but he's also stuck in it, chasing something he can't quite name, content for now to just stay hidden in the shadows. (5/10)

Comments